Finding An Anniversary Gift That Truly Shows How Much You Care Is Hard.

Dinners get forgotten. Gadgets gather dust. Bottles drain in days.

You want something that's personal — a gift that proves how well you know them — but finding it can feel impossible.

There's A Better Way To Gift

We Make It Simple To Give Something That Feels Extraordinary.

We get it — it should be easier to give the perfect anniversary gift.

That’s why we’ve helped countless people turn their love stories into custom vinyl records.

With hi-fi sound, full-color artwork, and hand-crafted vinyl, we make it simple to create a keepsake that feels personal, lasting, and unforgettable.


3 Easy Steps to the Perfect Anniversary Gift

Step 1 – Pick Your Vinyl

Choose the size and style that matches your moment — from classic black to bold picture discs.

Step 2 – Select Your Songs

Choose the sounds that define your love story — upload songs, wedding vows, and/or any other audio memories.

Step 3 – Add Your Artwork

Personalize it with photos or artwork so it looks and feels as unique as your story.

Then We Do The Rest

We’ll handcraft your record and ship it fast — so you can relax knowing their gift will arrive on time and ready to wow.


Step 1: Pick Your Vinyl

Don’t Let Another Anniversary Gift Fall Flat.

Every year, another anniversary passes - and another gift gets forgotten.

Don’t let this milestone slip by with a generic gift that disappears as soon as the night ends.

Create something that will be treasured, played, and displayed for decades.

Give A Better Gift

Give The Gift They’ll Never Forget.

Imagine the moment they open it — a vinyl record made just for them. Their photos on the cover. Their songs on the disc.

When the needle drops and your story comes to life, they’ll know exactly how much they mean to you.

This isn’t just a gift. It’s your love, pressed on vinyl, ready to last a lifetime.

Start Your Custom Vinyl

Create Your Vinyl Now And Be the Most Thoughtful Gift Giver in the Room.

"This is perfect. My husband was basically in tears, which never happens. He absolutely loves it!" - Jenny D.
Examples

12" Full-Color Picture Disc — The Showstopper

  • Our most popular and most personal record. Your photos are incorporated into the vinyl itself, turning your love story into a playable work of art. With 20 minutes of hi-fi sound per side, it looks as incredible as it sounds — a gift they’ll never stop showing off.
  • The #1 choice for unforgettable milestone moments.

Examples of 12-inch picture disc records with custom artwork for record cover and vinyl image

12" Solid-Color Vinyl — Bold, Modern, and Beautiful

  • If you want something that stands out but keeps it sleek, this one’s for you. Choose from rich, eye-catching colors that feel as unique as your story — with 20 minutes of music per side and a full-color printed cover.
  • A perfect balance of style, sound, and sentiment — a close second to the Picture Disc.

Examples of 12-inch solid-color vinyl with custom artwork for record cover and inner label

7" & 12" Classic Black — Timeless, Simple, and Thoughtful

  • Nothing says “vinyl” quite like classic black. Available in 7” (7 minutes per side) or 12” (20 minutes per side), it’s the perfect keepsake when you want something meaningful and budget-friendly.
  • A simple classic — and an easy way to start your custom vinyl tradition.

Examples of 7 and 12-inch black vinyl with custom artwork for record cover and inner label

Which Vinyl Is Best For You?

Every love story is different — and so is every record we make. Here’s a quick guide to help you find the vinyl that fits your moment best.

12" Picture Disc (Best Seller)
Sale price$109.00Regular price $179.00
12" Solid-Color
Sale price$99.00Regular price $119.00
12" Black
Sale price$79.00Regular price $99.00
7" Black
Sale price$49.00Regular price $69.00
Max. Minutes of Audio Per Side

20

20

20

7

Can I Upload My Own Audio?

YES

YES

YES

YES

Custom Record Cover Photos/Artwork

YES

YES

YES

YES

Custom Inner Label Photos/Artwork

NO

YES

YES

YES

Solid-Color Vinyl Option

NO

YES

NO

NO

Picture Disc Option

YES

NO

NO

NO

About Us

Hey — we’re John & Rebecca. We started Custom Vinyl Playlist because we were tired of giving gifts that didn’t mean anything.

We wanted something that actually felt personal — the kind of gift that makes someone pause, smile, and maybe tear up a little.

So we built this: a way to turn your favorite songs and memories into a handcrafted record that lasts forever.

Take a look at this quick video to see how your story comes to life on vinyl.

Build Your Record

FAQs

Still wondering if this is right for you? Here’s everything you need to know.

How do I create my vinyl record?

First, choose your vinyl size, 7" or 12", depending on how much audio you want to include. Then select your style, whether classic black, a solid color of your choosing, or our full-color picture disc, which is our #1 best seller.

Second, add your audio files.

Third, add your artwork. This can be as simple as uploading a photo from your phone or any custom artwork you've created.

How many songs can I add?

You can include up to 14 minutes of audio on a 7” record (7 minutes per side) and up to 40 minutes on a 12” (20 minutes per side).

What kind of audio files can I use and how do I upload them?

As soon as you start building your record, you can add any type of audio you want directly from your device - songs, voice recordings, vows, toasts, etc.

We can accept WAV, WMV, AAC, MP3, and M4A file formats.

If you’re on a computer, you can upload music you’ve downloaded or purchased from places like the Apple iTunes Store, Amazon Music, Bandcamp, Beatport, Qobuz, and others — as well as any files you already own. (Google Play Music no longer offers downloads, so you’ll want to use one of the options above instead.)

If you’re on a mobile device, note that songs downloaded from the iTunes Store can’t be uploaded directly from your phone because of Apple’s iOS permissions. For those tracks, you’ll just need to switch to a computer to download your files and then complete your uploads.

You can also use files saved elsewhere — like Google Drive, Dropbox, or your desktop — just download them and drop them right into your record. It’s quick and easy.

By uploading your audio, you’re agreeing to our Terms of Service.

What artwork dimensions and formats will look best?

Upload all photos, images, and custom artwork in JPG/JPEG format.

We print in super high-quality 300DPI. If it looks good on your device, it should look good printed. We'll reach out to you if we think there's a problem with your art.

When you upload your art in our Record Builder, you can frame it as you like without needing precise art dimensions. Yet, if you want to ensure the highest quality and most accurate reproduction, submit your art with these square dimensions:

  • 12" Record Cover width and height: 3675 pixels or 12.25 inches
  • 12" Picture Disc image/photo/art width and height: 3540 pixels or 11.8 inches
  • 12" and 7" Inner Label width and height: 990 pixels or 3.3 inches
  • 7" Record Cover width and height: 2185 pixels or 7.3 inches
  • Keep in mind that inner labels and picture disc images are circular, so the corners of your square images will be cut off. You can see what it looks like framed in the Record Builder.
How is the sound quality and playability?

These are genuine records that play beautifully. Each is hand-cut, not factory-pressed, which gives it an authentic, warm vinyl sound. You may hear the classic pops and crackles that make vinyl feel nostalgic and timeless. The volume is about 1dB quieter than a pressed record and, unless you know exactly what 1dB sounds like and you're an audiophile doing a back-to-back comparison with a studio-pressed album on an amazing home stereo, you won't hear a difference (and even then it will be hard to know which is which)

Do I need a record player to enjoy it?

Not at all. Many customers buy them as beautiful display pieces. And, if you do have a turntable, it makes the experience even more special.

How long does it take?

We make these by hand one-by-one, so standard turnaround is 10–14 business days. Need it sooner? Rush processing is available after you check out.

What if something isn’t perfect, or I need to make changes?

We guarantee every record. If yours isn’t flawless, we’ll remake it free. We put your record into production usually within a few hours of your order submittal, so it may or may not be possible to make changes.

Your Love Story Deserves More Than a Generic Gift

Every couple has their story — the moments, the laughter, the songs that made it theirs.

Now you can press those memories on vinyl — made by hand, crafted with care, and ready to last a lifetime.

Start Your Custom Vinyl